EMInfo Logo
The Original Resource for the Staffing and Recruiting Industry
Image

Recruiters get return phone calls

Published: Dec 24, 2021 12:15 PM  |  By Michael Gionta  |  Viewed: 2391
Category: Columns, Expert Advice, Productivity, Recruiting  |  Tags: Recruiting, Marketing, Search, Hiring

 

QUESTION: Mike, do you have suggestions for leaving messages to get return phone calls? 

-Howard 

ANSWER: I do not know what messages you are leaving now, but I find vague messages are better.  If you are leaving detailed messages about, for example, on a recruiting call, “I am working on this assignment and here are the 17 reasons why it is interesting and call me back”, I find those get returned less and usually deleted.  

One of the techniques I use and have taught, because it is harder to get return phone calls, is to start all of your messages like this:  “My name is Mike Gionta.  My phone number is (860) . . .”  Note that I do not say Mike Gionta with “X” Firm.  

The message starts with “My name is Mike Gionta.  Phone number . . .” for a very specific reason.  When they are writing the phone number, their hand is not on the delete button, or it less likely to be.  

If it is a recruit call, my message would continue saying “I have no idea what your current situation is.  I just thought I would talk to you kind of quietly and confidentially to see if you are open to hearing about something potentially stronger than your current situation. Curious as to your thoughts on that.  Again, Mike Gionta.”  

Now, I have not said I am with a search firm or anything about my search firm such as  “We are founded with the Pilgrims.”  Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.  If you go into that detail they will automatically know that I am a recruiter.  I do not want to waste words, and I have built a little intrigue.  

On the marketing side, back to the beginning of the call.  As part of a followup process, I am usually leading with an employer with an email and a candidate, unless I am doing a flip marketing call and then I am leaving basically that same message, very short, very brief.  It still gets a lot of return calls.  What I do notice is if you want to call hiring managers and not do a flip marketing call, meaning you are not trying to recruit them first, I find it is best to send an email, if you are sending an email of a candidate.  

So the first step would be an email.  “I have recently uncovered an individual who ___ (big accomplishment) ___, saved a company $1,237,000 in tax savings in the tax department, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, by finding and uncovering 2 legal loopholes the company previously had not taken advantage of.  This person is adept at finding and uncovering and can do the same for you.”  That quick.  

Now, I might send that email a couple times.  There are a few different ways we do that.  The third call might be “Joe, I sent you a couple emails.  I recently uncovered . . .” and it would be the same thing.  The voicemail would be the same as the emails.  But they are building off of the message they have already seen.  So I am in a repetition mode in that sense. 

There are a few techniques to get more returned voicemails. Create intrigue. Approach your marketing calls with a combination of emails and voicemails.

Michael Gionta

Written by

Michael Gionta

Michael Gionta has over 20 years successfully growing his own recruiting firm that ranked in the top 3% of all MRI offices Worldwide. In addition, Michael is now sought out by owners who want to grow their recruiting firms but simply lack the “recipe” for doing so. His programs provide a step-by-step process that quickly be put into place to begin the journey of getting control of your business with profits that seemed out of reach before. Email Mike at info@TheRecruiterU.com to see if or how his programs can benefit you.

Read More from Michael Gionta
More Articles in This Category
The Rise of the Chief AI Officer

Oct 28, 2026

Jeremy Sisemore

For more than two decades, the Chief Information Officer (CIO) has been one of the most critical roles in Corporate Amer...

Finding Your Cadence - Adapting to Market Shifts in Recruitment

Oct 28, 2026

Michael Gionta

QUESTION: Mike, how are you seeing the recruiting market as we read the global news? Understanding the Recruiting Marke...

Profit from Locum Tenens Staffing!

Oct 28, 2026

Judy Collins

Placing Locum Tenens is a specialized recruiting model. In staffing, it generally refers to physicians and certain advan...

FEATURED ARTICLES
The Staffing KPIs that Predict a Good Quarter or a Painful One
The Staffing KPIs that Predict a Good Quarter or a Painful One

As we are knee deep in quarter 4, there is no better time than the present to monitor how you are...

By Jennifer Roeslmeier Mikels

October 28, 2026  |  145

Expert Advice, Productivity

Placeholder Image
Engineers in Demand!

With all the current economic activity, especially in the manufacturing/industrial sector, I aske...

By Judy Collins

October 1, 2026  |  445

Columns, Expert Advice, Trends

Placeholder Image
The Evolution of a Recruiter .. and why it matters

If you’re an experienced recruiter, chances are you’re doing pretty well. The business has it...

By Steve Finkel

September 16, 2026  |  426

Expert Advice, Productivity, Recruiting